skip to main | skip to sidebar
  • Home
  • Archives
  • Content
  • Bookmark
  • Blogger
  • Subscribe

Interns Under 30

Can you be successfull at a job if you are overqualified?

Written by Unknown on Tuesday, March 30, 2010 at 12:01 AM

Sometimes you may have to take one step backward to move forward? Maybe when your parents told you that as a child you did not want to believe it. So as an unemployed skilled adult worker trying to find a new career can you live with it?

Overqualified? Yes, but Happy to Have a Job


GRANDVIEW, Mo. — Don Carroll, a former financial analyst with a master’s degree in business administration from a top university, was clearly overqualified for the job running the claims department for Cartwright International a small, family-owned moving company here south of Kansas City.
But he had been out of work for six months, and the department badly needed modernization after several decades of benign neglect. It turned out to be a perfect match.
After being hired in December, Mr. Carroll, 31, quickly set about revamping the four-person department, which settles damage claims from moves, and creating tracking tools so the company could better understand its spending.
Conventional wisdom warns against hiring overqualified candidates like Mr. Carroll, who often find themselves chafing at their new roles. (The posting for his job had specified “bachelor’s degree preferred but not required.”) But four months into his employment, it seems to be working out well for all involved.


It is a situation being repeated across the country as the aspirations of many workers have been recalibrated amid the recession, enabling some companies to reap unexpected rewards.
A result is a new cadre of underemployed workers dotting American companies, occupying slots several rungs below where they are accustomed to working. These are not the more drastic examples of former professionals toiling away at “survival jobs” at Home Depot or Starbucks. They are the former chief financial officer working as comptroller, the onetime marketing director who is back to being an analyst, the former manager who is once again an “individual contributor.”
The phenomenon was probably inevitable in a labor market in which job seekers outnumber openings five to one. Employers are seizing the opportunity to stock up on discounted talent, despite the obvious risks that the new hires will become dissatisfied and leave. “They’re trying to really professionalize this company,” said Mr. Carroll, who is the sole breadwinner for his family of four and had lost his home to foreclosure. “I’ve been able to play a big role in that.”

For Full Article From By MICHAEL LUO at The New York Time

4 comments
Categories: jobs
Share this post - Email This

i

4 Responses to "Can you be successfull at a job if you are overqualified?"

Comment by John E. Smith
March 30, 2010 at 6:31 AM #  

Interesting article and the full version gives a much richer and realistic picture of this phenomena.

To me, the essential ingredient here is always the individual's mindset, which determines both how they view being in a job that is "lower" than past positions and how they will approach their work in that "lower" job.

As the economy "rightsizes", this is going to become a more significant issue. Older workers, who are the bulk of those who might look back to "better days" are going to be in the workforce for a long time. The types and levels of jobs which we all used to take for granted are not coming back. Accepting a job that currently asks for less than we are capable of giving will become more usual.

However, we can still exercise our creativity and abilities in any position, even those working at Home Depot or Starbucks. Any position has the possibility for challenge, engagement, and positive return. We just have to see it and act on it.

Time to get mentally tough, America:) There are far worse things than having a job that you can do without maximum effort.

John

Anonymous
March 31, 2010 at 11:11 AM #  

John I think it is more than "a job that you can do without maximum effort" as employers often expect a lot from new employees no matter what their experience and skills may be!
I learned this to my detriment hoping to make a job change to a very small company that never had a sales person before and their expectations were extreme - easy work but no off time just total commitment ... and un realistic expectations.
Cheers
Thomas

Comment by Judy
April 1, 2010 at 8:54 AM #  

Accepting a job that you are overqualified means that you agree with the terms upon hiring. Now, are you going to be happy to have the job? It will depend on the choices you make when you go to work... either you be happy about it and enjoy the easier part of the job than you were used to or be gripy about it and go back to the unemployment line.

There will always be greater opportunity sooner or later... it's going to be competitive and challenging given the current economic situation but I think.. if we look at this as an opportunity to do our job and train those who needs help, it will help add value to the company and maybe, the next great opportunity for promotion is yours.

Judy

Comment by Rita
April 6, 2010 at 7:13 AM #  

Overqualified is a state of mind. The notion of overqualified is a judgement we sometimes make of ourselves and it is hurtful.

Overqualified is an overused cliche'. Just because you have done the job earlier in your career or have done more than the job at hand only means you have more experience to succeed at that job.

To claim you are overqualified is not especially useful. There is always something new in a job or at least a new approach to a job. Success is your objective and the more successful you are at a given job, the more responsibility you are given. Don't be fooled by job titles.

Many of the top companies hire VPs as directors, Directors as Sr. Managers and so on. It is their policy and it works. These companies over hire to insure they get the jobs done well with the least amount of surprises and the largest ability to handle any crisis. They value their employees and the employees are proud to be associated with the best companies in the world. [You know who they are.]

So forget the title and the notion of overqualified and focus on doing the job well. What feels better than sort of success?

Rita Ashley, Career Coach
Author: Job Search Debugged
Author: Networking Debugged

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (RSS)

About Interns Under 30

Are you a new college graduate, still in school or ready to try out a new career? Then check out our internship and job listings. Also our 100's of articles on how to find a new job.

Blogger Templates

Labels

  • actors (1)
  • adult education (34)
  • Advertisers (1)
  • advice (12)
  • advice adult education (1)
  • affiliate (1)
  • age bias (11)
  • ageism (10)
  • auto industry (2)
  • auto workers (2)
  • baby boomers (7)
  • baldwin (1)
  • boomers (4)
  • career advisors (208)
  • career branding (10)
  • career change (49)
  • career coach (12)
  • career management (93)
  • career marketplace resume interviewing branding (4)
  • career switch (45)
  • careers (28)
  • changing careers (44)
  • COACH resume interviewing education (1)
  • comment of the week (3)
  • comments (5)
  • contest (1)
  • contributing writers (1)
  • cover letters (10)
  • Daily quick link (1)
  • editoral career (1)
  • educate (7)
  • education (40)
  • employee appraisal (2)
  • employee morale (2)
  • employee performance appraisal (1)
  • employee productivity (1)
  • employees (31)
  • employers (93)
  • employment (75)
  • facebook (3)
  • faq (1)
  • female employees (2)
  • financial aid (1)
  • find an internship (23)
  • firing an employee (2)
  • forecast (1)
  • freelance (1)
  • guest bloggers (1)
  • guest writers (1)
  • headhunter (4)
  • health (1)
  • hiring employees (35)
  • how to (51)
  • HR (1)
  • human resources (21)
  • human resources advisors (19)
  • i (1)
  • ideo (1)
  • inter (1)
  • interns (24)
  • internship help (17)
  • internships (36)
  • internshjob seekers (2)
  • interview (5)
  • interview help (26)
  • interviewing (1)
  • introverts (1)
  • job (143)
  • job search (13)
  • job search tools (127)
  • job search toolsjobs (1)
  • job seekers (232)
  • jobs (163)
  • jobs linkedin social networking (3)
  • jobs volunteer (1)
  • laws (2)
  • le (1)
  • legislation (1)
  • lifestyle (7)
  • linkedin (13)
  • loans (1)
  • mature workers (11)
  • Members Only (1)
  • mentor (2)
  • mentoring (3)
  • mentors (2)
  • motivating employees (3)
  • networking (20)
  • news (79)
  • occupations (2)
  • older workers (12)
  • online branding (4)
  • personal branding (4)
  • phone interviews (4)
  • recareer (7)
  • recareering (6)
  • recession (5)
  • recruiters (81)
  • recuiting (29)
  • references (2)
  • relocation (1)
  • resume (6)
  • resume cover letter jobs (2)
  • resumes (16)
  • returnships (1)
  • rewarding employees (1)
  • small business (1)
  • social media (11)
  • social networking (21)
  • streep (1)
  • stress (6)
  • teamwork (3)
  • tips (39)
  • top 10 content (11)
  • transferable skills (8)
  • unemployment (6)
  • video (63)
  • volunteering (1)
  • watchboom.com (1)
  • web 2.0 (1)
  • weekly summary (10)
  • women (2)
  • writing memos (1)